The Cross as Counter-Script


The Cross as Counter-Script
Brian Zahnd

As Americans we are given a script from birth — it is our shared and assumed formula for the pursuit of happiness. Without even being aware of it we are scripted in the belief that our superior technology, our self-help programs, our dominant military, and our capacity to obtain consumer goods should guarantee our happiness. Said just so it sounds silly, but when it is communicated in the liturgies of advertising and the propaganda of state it becomes believable…and we do believe it. Give me a new iPhone, a motivational talk, a trillion dollar war machine, a Visa card, and I can be happy! For the most part the Americanized church has unconsciously bought into this script and concocted a compromised Christianity to endorse the script point for point. It’s Americanism with a Jesus fish bumper sticker. But in the end the desperate pursuit of the brass ring of happiness — even when “Christianized” by the prosperity gospel — leads to a shriveled and disappointed soul. In the final analysis the American script is shamed by the cross of Christ.

The Enlightenment promise that technology would lead to Utopia has been weighed in the balances of history and found wanting. It went up in smoke — literal smoke! — in the gray ashes of Auschwitz and a hideous mushroom cloud over Hiroshima. Gullible faith in the ability of technology to automatically produce a better world should now be seen as a naïve anachronism.

A Christian obsession with therapeutic self-help fads reveals how disconnected we are from substantive historic theology and the ancient practice of spiritual direction. Today we have pastors mimicking one another by replacing their pulpit with a bed and giving their congregation a “thirty-day sex challenge.” Please. These silly gimmicks oscillate between ludicrous and pathetic.

Superstitious reverence for all things military constantly verges on the idolatrous and prevents the church from being a prophetic people. Memorial Day is not on the church calendar and military color guards marching down church aisles with rifles on their shoulders should not be part of our liturgy.

Consumerism, as much as anything, has come to define much of America’s most visible expressions of Christianity. Take a quick stroll though “Christian TV Land” and you’ll see what I mean. This is what Janis Joplin mocked when she sang, “Oh Lord, won’t you buy me a Mercedes Benz.” The cross heaps shame on all of this.

The American prescription for happiness is the script we’ve been handed. But it’s a lie. It’s a false gospel, yet enormously popular. The only possible way to resist that dominant script is through the adoption of what Walter Brueggemann calls a counter-script. For the Christian that counter-script is the gospel of Jesus Christ — at the center of which stands a cross!

When we are trying to relocate the center of authentic Christianity we are led to Calvary. Jesus promised paradise, not to those who prioritize personal happiness, but to one who was dying on a cross beside him. Father John Behr closes his brilliant little book Becoming Human with this meditation on the cross.

“Our journey through this world, dying to this world as ‘Egypt,’ through baptism, then dying as we sojourn in the desert of this world by taking up the cross daily, refashions us as living human beings, human beings living in this world as God’s paradise at the center of which stand the cross, the tree of life. ‘Truly I say to you, today you will be with me in Paradise,’ says Christ to the one willing to be crucified with him. Are we ready, now, to live?”Becoming Human by John Behr, pp. 108, 109

In contemplating the cross we find the counter-script to Americanized Christianity. In drawing near to the cross we find the portal to a deeper, richer, fuller Christianity. But the cross is a costly portal. The price of admission is death. It means losing your false life to find your true life. The path to paradise is often the path of suffering. If our chief goal is to avoid suffering, we will probably never find paradise. Paradise is not found in the mall, it’s found on the Easter side of Good Friday.


(The artwork is Crucifixion by Andrea del Castagno, 1450)

  • Steven Spears

    Arthur Booth-Clibborn offers the same critique to European Christianty in his Blood Against Blood just before WWI broke out. We have failed to learn our lesson.

  • ERSchindler

    Thanks Brian for so incisively exposing many of the lies we all buy into, and build our very lives upon.

  • Another excellent post, Brian.

    (Permit me to point out a typo: in the third paragraph from the end, “mediation” should be “meditation”.)

  • Thank you.

  • Herm

    “Whoever comes to me and does not hate father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters, yes, and even life itself, cannot be my disciple. Whoever does not carry the cross and follow me cannot be my disciple. Luke 14:26-27

    I have said this to you, so that in me you may have peace. In the world you face persecution. But take courage; I have conquered the world!” John 16:33

    Jesus said to them again, “Peace be with you. As the Father has sent me, so I send you.” When he had said this, he breathed on them and said to them, “Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained.” John 20:21-23

    Thank you, Pastor Zahnd! Love you!

  • I am interested in how believers from other, formerly non-Christian regions, respond to the Americanized Christianity. As an African, I have found two common responses, (1) adoption and (2) protest. In adoption, millions of Christians in Africa are blindly following the Americanized Christianity, hence the proliferation of ‘prosperity gospel’ among other tainted forms of Christianity. In protest, there is a mushrooming of the Boko Haram Christianity where believers are taught to loathe anything deemed Western. The church need to heed the impact of Americanized Christianity. Thank you for the post.

  • Guest


  • A wonderful and timely post! I shared it in a facebook group I just started for the purpose of bringing awareness of the script Christians already live without knowing it and to promote the only alternate script of the Gospel of the Crucified King. If you want to check it out: Many thanks!

  • Jennifer A. Nolan

    Dear Nyasha Dzoga;
    Your people’s situation is tragic. They have been listening to Western imperialist missionaries for too long. There is enough literacy in Africa for many people to read and interpret the Gospel for themselves, so they don’t have to listen to most Americans with big, idolatrous ideas anymore. As for Boko Haram anti-Europeanism, I think good critical thinking, and serious prayer, will allow your people to eventually sort out the good from the bad in Western ideas and influences. There is a lot to love in European and North American ideas of liberty, equality, personal dignity, and public health, but please turn off the U.S. noise machine!

  • Aaron Thomas

    Brian, here I am sitting in a coffee shop, crying from reading these powerful and inspiring words. Thank you for your boldness and prophetic voice. They are an inspiration to a young church planter like myself.

  • Johan Van Reenen

    What we are seeing in the church today is what Paul wrote to Timothy so many years ago: 2 Timothy 4:3-4 “For the time will come when they will not endure sound doctrine, but according to their own desires, because they have itching ears, they will heap up for themselves teachers; and they will turn their ears away from the truth, and be turned aside to fables.” (NKJV)

    Jesus also asked this profound question: Luke 18:8 “Nevertheless, when the Son of Man comes, will he find faith on earth?” (ESV) The implied answer to this question is “No.”

    We must therefore not be surprised at what is happening in the church today. Those who will be saved will be few: Luke 13:23-24 “And someone said to him, “Lord, will those who are saved be few?” And he said to them, “Strive to enter through the narrow door. For many, I tell you, will seek to enter and will not be able.”” (ESV)