All posts in Uncategorized

  • The God Who Suffers

    An online acquaintance said this:

    Pardon me while I think out loud, as it were. I had occasion last night to sit and ponder death. Within 20 minutes I discovered it had impacted two people that are a part of my and Dryad’s life.

    There is a woman in our neighborhood we call the tamale lady. Every couple of weeks she comes around selling pork, beef and chicken tamales that she has made by hand, 7$ a dozen. There are delicious; we buy them almost every time she comes. I hadn’t seen her in several weeks, then last night she showed up the usual smile absent from her face, but carrying the familiar bag. I asked her how she had been, and told her we’d missed her and worried for her, which was true. She said she hadn’t been in the mood, or had the time in a while. Then she pointed to the sky and said,”My husband, he go away April 26.” Tears leaped up to my eyes, all I could say was I was sorry. We exchanged tamales and money, and she walked off a sad smile on her face.

    He then went on to make several thoughtful observations and closed with this:

    Overlaid all of this is the fact that God Himself promises, there will be no more fear, no more pain, no more grief and suffering, and that the wounds we carried will be healed and soothed by His own hand. How can I not desire that place? My true home, in time to come, where I will have all of time to explore God’s handiwork to my great delight and contentment, and in so doing worship Him in a way I was made to do so, with all of those who, throughout history, have loved Him for his great mercy and compassion.

    Now, let me share with you my response:

    Some random thoughts inspired by your out loud thinking:

    This world is not my home.

    Do you know who first thought and said that? The Gnostics. The first Christian heretics. Gnosticism was a dualism heresy; a kind of Greek re-working of Buddhist dualism.

    This world is my home! And the blessed hope is not going to heaven, but God setting right a world gone wrong. Heaven is a interim stop between death and the resurrection and new creation. The hope of the Gospel is fulfilled in the resurrection. Yes, I believe in life after death. But more importantly, I believe in life after life after death. In other words, I’m no Platonist or neo-Gnostic satisfied with a disembodied state in the realm of ethereal forms — I am a Christian longing for the resurrection of the dead and a world set to rights!

    One of the tenants of Gnosticism that survived the various councils was the doctrine of divine impassibility. It is a doctrine that says God is impassive and derives no pain or pleasure from the action of beings outside Himself; i.e. God is without emotion. This philosophy was originally developed by Plato and Aristotle and then co-opted by the early church fathers who were prone to be far more Greco-Christian than Judeo-Christian. Origen, Augustine, Aquinas, Calvin all believed in divine impassibility. In fact, one could say that all of the church fathers, medieval theologians and Reformed theologians (with the exception of Luther) believed in divine impassibility. The notion that God is impassive, emotionless and cannot suffer was the orthodox position until the 20th century.

    Suffering.

    That’s the issue here.

    Gnosticism was largely an attempt to develop a doctrine where all suffering could be eliminated. It plotted a course very similar to that of Siddhartha Gautama (Buddha) involving attaining a state of detachment (impassivity). Of course to develop a doctrine wherein there is the potential escape from all suffering, you must make freedom form suffering an attribute of God. Thus, divine impassibility or the God who cannot suffer.

    As I said, divine impassibility was widely accepted by theologians until the 20th century. But today divine impassibility is almost entirely rejected. What happened?

    The Holocaust.

    The Holocaust forced theologians to reconsider divine impassibility. Could God really be impassive to such horrific human suffering? The instinctive answer is, no.

    The other effect the Holocaust had on theological thought was it forced the church to face its tacit anti-Semitism. In so doing, theologians “discovered” that Jesus was Jewish and that Christianity has Jewish roots. Of course the God of the Jewish scriptures (the Old Testament) was never impassive and emotionless; the God of Israel was so connected to His people in covenant that He suffered with them and experienced a wide range of emotions. It was Plato and Aristotle that gave the notion of divine impassibility to the church, not Moses or Paul. And the bottom line is Plato is not a prophet and Aristotle is not an apostle.

    The doctrine of divine impassibility died in the Holocaust.

    Writing from his Nazi prison cell a short time before his execution a 38 year old Lutheran pastor and theologian by the name of Dietrich Bonhoeffer said this:

    Only the suffering God can help.

    What help can an emotionless God who cannot suffer be to a suffering people?

    But God does suffer…with us and for us.

    By His wounds we are healed.

    As far as I’m concerned the doctrine of divine impassibility can be dashed to pieces with the shortest verse in the Bible:

    Jesus wept.

    God has suffered. God does suffer. God suffers because He wills to love. God is not impassive, God is love.

    Holocaust survivor and Nobel laureate, Elie Wiesel, has often said, “The opposite of love is not hatred, but indifference.”

    God is not indifferent, God is love.

    Elie Wiesel tells of three Jews being hung while he was at Auschwitz; two men and a youth. The two men died quickly, but the youth hung by his neck for half an hour. While being forced to watch this horrible spectacle a voice behind Elie asked, “Where is God?” A little while later the voice again asked, “Where is He?” Elie answered, “He is here, he is on the gallows.”

    In a mystical way Elie Wiesel is right. God has hung on a gallows. The gallows of the cross. He suffered and died upon the gallows of the cross.

    And Jesus rose from the dead. Death is defeated. Death is not the end. Death is not the death that used to be. And this is the hope I have for the world: The resurrection of the dead the dawn of a new creation. And quite honestly, I know of no other hope. This is the hope for all the “tamale ladies” of this broken world.

    Yes, the problem of pain is a problem for the theist. But it is just as big a problem for the atheist. The atheist has to explain why there is a sense of justice in the first place and why Dostoevsky’s Ivan Karamazov is not right in saying, “Without God all things are permitted.” No one really wants to live in a world were “all things are permitted” anarchists be damned (and they are — Satan himself being the ultimate anarchist!). In a world without God what is the foundation for justice? Or why is there even the idea of justice? An ontological argument for justice leads to the Ontological Argument for God. Thus the problem of pain for the atheist.

    I’ve thought much about the philosophical implications of death a lot over the past few years and I have arrived at this conclusion: You have two honest options…

    Jesus Christ or Friedrich Nietzsche.

    The will to power or the will to love.

    God is dead or God has risen from the dead.

    The Superman of the Son of Man.

    The Ubermensch or the Incarnation.

    Anything in between is either shoddy thinking or a cowardly cop out.

    I’ve made my choice.

    I choose Jesus.
    I choose the Son of Man.
    I choose the Incarnation.
    I choose the will to love.
    I choose the God who died.
    I choose the God who rose again.
    I choose the God who suffers.
    I choose the God who heals.

    This is my hope!

    Maranatha!

    BZ

  • What has Athens to do with Jerusalem?

    What has Athens to do with Jerusalem?

    This is the question raised by the second century church leader, Tertullian.

    What does Athens as the center of Greek philosophy have to do with Jerusalem as the center of Jewish revelation?

    What do the Greek philosophers have to do with the Jewish prophets?

    These are important questions, and not just historically; they have important implications for today.

    Tertullian’s question should not be understood as, “What does thought have to do with theology?” or “What does philosophy have to do with Christianity?” Thought and theology are inseparable and philosophy simply means “the love of wisdom” and the Bible clearly calls us to love wisdom.

    Rather, Tertullian’s rhetorical question has to do with what is the foundation and final authority for divine knowledge?

    I believe Tertullian’s question could be expanded in this manner: What do the Greek gods have to do with the God of Israel and when push comes to shove who do you side with, Plato or Moses?

    For all the appreciation I have for the early church fathers, I can’t countenance their man-crush on Plato. It really does seem that they wanted to make Plato a prophet and Aristotle an apostle. They were not.

    Pre-existent souls…Divine Impassibility (the doctrine that God is impassive, emotionless and incapable of suffering)…over-emphasis on heaven…tacit belief that physical bodies are evil…sexuality diminishes spirituality…this world is not our home, etc. These are all ideas derived from Greek philosophers that are in opposition to revelation given by the Jewish prophets.

    Judeo-Christian or Greco-Christian?

    That’s the question.

    The answer should be Judeo-Christian, but for much of the church the reality has been Greco-Christian.

    Of course not everything from the Greek philosophers and poets is wrong. That’s not the point. But can we discover the true nature of God and ultimate reality by philosophical thought alone or is divine revelation required to get the ball rolling? In other words, is a philosopher enough or do you need a prophet?

    Answer: You need revelation. You need a prophet.

    Rene Descartes said, “I think, therefore I am.”

    And this is the foundation for empiricism.

    But Moses records God as saying, “I AM THAT I AM.”

    And this is the foundation for revelation.

    These are two different beginning points:
    From inside your own head: “I think, therefore I am.”
    From external revelation: “I AM THAT I AM.”

    Is empiricism enough to give you all the knowledge you need or is revelation with corresponding faith required?

    At this point let me again quote Tertullian: “I believe because it is absurd.”

    The relationship between faith and absurdity was especially appreciated by Pascal and Kierkegaard — so don’t give me any lip about belief in the absurd being merely a cover for ignorance (because we all know that Pascal and Kierkegaard are both way smarter than anyone reading this blog).

    The Greek philosophers can make valuable contributions to thought, but they have nothing to contribute to revelation, and revelation is where we must begin in the realm of the knowledge of God.

    In general, we need to think more Jewish and less Greek.
    More like Paul than Plato.
    More like David than Homer.

    Especially in these categories:
    Heaven/Earth
    Spirit/Body
    Determinism/Choice
    Death/Resurrection

    We are looking for the New Jerusalem, not the New Athens.

    BZ

    PS

    Various thoughts:

    I like the ESV (English Standard Version).

    It’s time for me to get in mountain shape. I need to push it pretty hard beginning today!

    My big climb for this summer is McHenrys Peak via Stoneman Pass. Generally considered the most difficult 3rd class peak in Rocky Mountain National Park.

    Here are some photos from my online climbing counselor, Smudge:

    McHenrys Peak

    Another view of McHenrys
    With Longs and Chief’s Head in the background

    Just below Stoneman Pass
    That’s Longs Peak in the background. A few days earlier I will lead a group of guys up Longs Peak — my ninth climb of Longs. I charge them all a dollar…that way I can call myself a professional mountain guide. Ha!

    Looking down the south ridge

    I do love the mountains!

    Song in my head today:

    High Water (For Charley Patton)
    by Bob Dylan

    High water risin’ – risin’ night and day
    All the gold and silver are being stolen away
    Big Joe Turner lookin’ East and West
    From the dark room of his mind
    He made it to Kansas City
    Twelfth Street and Vine
    Nothing standing there
    High water everywhere

    High water risin’, the shacks are slidin’ down
    Folks lose their possessions – folks are leaving town
    Bertha Mason shook it – broke it
    Then she hung it on a wall
    Says, “You’re dancin’ with whom they tell you to
    Or you don’t dance at all.”
    It’s tough out there
    High water everywhere

    I got a cravin’ love for blazing speed
    Got a hopped up Mustang Ford
    Jump into the wagon, love, throw your panties overboard
    I can write you poems, make a strong man lose his mind
    I’m no pig without a wig
    I hope you treat me kind
    Things are breakin’ up out there
    High water everywhere

    High water risin’, six inches ‘bove my head
    Coffins droppin’ in the street
    Like balloons made out of lead
    Water pourin’ into Vicksburg, don’t know what I’m going to do
    “Don’t reach out for me,” she said
    “Can’t you see I’m drownin’ too?”
    It’s rough out there
    High water everywhere

    Well, George Lewis told the Englishman, the Italian and the Jew
    “You can’t open your mind, boys
    To every conceivable point of view.”
    They got Charles Darwin trapped out there on Highway Five
    Judge says to the High Sheriff,
    “I want him dead or alive
    Either one, I don’t care.”
    High Water everywhere

    The Cuckoo is a pretty bird, she warbles as she flies
    I’m preachin’ the Word of God
    I’m puttin’ out your eyes
    I asked Fat Nancy for something to eat, she said, “Take it off the shelf –
    As great as you are a man,
    You’ll never be greater than yourself.”
    I told her I didn’t really care
    High water everywhere

    I’m getting’ up in the morning – I believe I’ll dust my broom
    Keeping away from the women
    I’m givin’ ’em lots of room
    Thunder rolling over Clarksdale, everything is looking blue
    I just can’t be happy, love
    Unless you’re happy too
    It’s bad out there
    High water everywhere

  • Stop Using the Bible

    Here’s a thought: Stop using the Bible.

    Don’t stop reading it. Don’t stop thinking it. Don’t stop speaking it.

    But please stop using it.

    But that is exactly what many in the evangelical world are prone to do with the Bible…make it practical and useful. Like a tool.

    The Bible as an appliance.

    Keep it around in a handy location until you need something done. Then fetch your Bible like a blender from the cabinet.

    It slices, it dices, it makes life easy.

    Oh, yeah, we even advertise our teaching of the Bible in this manner:

    “PRACTICAL SERMONS”

    Because we all know that Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount, Paul’s revelation concerning Israel in Romans and John’s prophetic poetry in Revelation are all very “practical.”

    (You do know sarcasm when you see it, don’t you?)

    Someone else tells me “the Bible is the owner’s manual for life.”

    Well, isn’t that cute. Of course there’s no truth in it whatsoever. I’ve got lots of owner’s manuals — for just about every appliance I own — and none of them read anything like the Bible! (When was the last time you saw an owner’s manual full of prophecy and poetry?)

    The Bible is nothing like a manual.
    It’s an epic poem telling a story.
    And the story’s not about you.
    The story is about Emmanuel.

    Using the Bible. There’s something very American about that. We Americans have a compulsion to make everything practical and useful — even God! We want to domesticate God so that we can harness Him to our agenda. We don’t want a God who is wild (like Aslan) — because wild can be dangerous (and very impractical). You can use what is domesticated.

    But you cannot worship what is domesticated.

    A pagan might worship a lion or leopard. But I doubt that even the most idolatrous pagan would worship a blender. It’s practical.

    OK, so you’re still wondering, what’s wrong with using the Bible?

    What’s wrong is it presumes that you know what needs to be done and that all you need is the means by which to get it done. What’s wrong is that it leaves you in charge of your own spiritual formation. What’s wrong is that it ultimately makes the word of God subservient to self.

    Think about Luke’s account of the Temptation of Christ. In the first and second temptations Jesus counters Satan with, “it is written.” But in the third temptation, Satan says to Jesus upon the pinnacle of the temple:

    If you are the Son of God, throw yourself down from here, for it is written:
    “He will command His angels concerning you,
    To guard you,
    On their hands they will bear you up,
    Lest you strike your foot against a stone.”

    If Jesus was “using” the Bible, he could have seized this promise, made practical use of it, applied to his life…and leaped from the temple.

    And sinned.

    Instead, Jesus simply replied:

    It is said, “You shall not put the Lord your God to the test.”

    No, we must not use the Bible as a tool to attain our own desired outcome, because in doing so we will be able to justify everything from tempting God with flying leaps to betraying the Gospel with genocidal crusades.

    Instead we must present ourselves before the scriptures and allow them to form us. Allow them to form us, inform us, transform us. Allow them to say to us whatever they want to say irrespective of our wants and desires. Submit yourself to the scriptures instead of using Bible verses as fiats so that God can be taught to fetch.

    Do you ever wonder just what God requires?
    You think He’s just an errand boy to satisfy your wandering desires.

    Here’s what you should do. Present yourself before the word of God day by day and let it so saturate your being that you don’t have to try to “use” the scriptures, but instead the scriptures have so formed your thinking and speaking that you find yourself being transformed by a renewed mind and moving mountains by spoken words — but not words that you use as a tool, but words that have formed you and become a part of you.

    Is there a difference?

    The difference between Jesus and the Pharisees.

    Think about it.

    I’ll say more Friday night.

    BZ

    PS

    Peri and I have been married for 27 years today.

    I can’t imagine doing life any other way than as brianandperi.

  • Achievable Satiation

    Walter Brueggemann in his book The Prophetic Imagination talks about the paradigm of “Achievable Satiation.”

    Let’s define terms.

    satiate: to satisfy desire to excess

    We live in a age committed to the idea of achievable satiation.

    Proverbs says…

    There are three things that are never satisfied,
    Yea, four that never say “Enough!”
    The grave
    The barren womb
    The thirsty desert
    The blazing fire

    I think we can now add a fifth:
    Our generation in search of satisfaction.

    Seeking to satisfy desire to excess. That’s our age in a nutshell!

    The present paradigm of achievable satiation has redefined our notion of what it is to be human, and it has done so to all of us. It has created a culture concerned only with self-satisfaction.

    And the church has not been exempt. We have been affected in many ways. For example: The practical denial of history and community.

    We have denied our own history to the point that we are a generation of the church suffering from collective amnesia. And in denying our history we also deny our future. We have so enthroned the present in the idolatrous “NOW” that a promised future, delayed but certain, is unthinkable.

    And we have denied our community. The radical emphasis on self within the corrupt paradigm of achievable satiation (Babylon!) has so fostered individualism that it has denied the very concept of community that calls us to care.

    Achievable satiation is fed by a management mentality that believes there are no mysteries to honor, only problems to be solved. There are no heroic battles to be won, only systems to be managed.

    Achievable satiation is endorsed by a consumer Christianity which believes God has no business other than maintaining our standard of living and in every way making our lives as comfortable as possible.

    Achievable satiation. It really is the religion of the day. The official religion of the empire.

    But here’s the kicker. Satiation is derived from a Latin word that means…get this…sad! Satiation comes from the word meaning sad. That’s sad! We are a culture committed to a paradigm of satisfaction that is designed to inevitably make us sad.

    And I can’t help but be reminded of the hook line from Sheryl Crow’s song, If It Makes You Happy. (Pardon the mild expletive, but it helps make the point.)

    If it makes you happy
    It can’t be that bad
    If it makes you happy
    Then why the hell are you so sad?

    Good question, Sheryl.

    The generation committed to the paradigm of achievable satiation is not going to find achievable satisfaction but achievable sadness.

    (And of course you can all quote Mick Jagger at this point.)

    So Sheryl observes that it just makes you sad and Mick confesses he can’t get no satisfaction. Perhaps we should look beyond the observations and confessions of rock stars and consider what Jesus said:

    “If anyone wants to be my follower you must put aside your selfish ambition, shoulder your cross, and follow me. If you try to keep your life for yourself, you will lose it. But if you give up your life for my sake and the sake of the Good News, you will find your true life. And how do you benefit if you gain the whole world [achievable satiation] but lose your own soul in the process? Is anything worth more than your soul?” (Mark 8:34-37, NLT)

    Achievable Satiation?

    No.

    Take up the cross.

    Achievable Crucifixion.

    Achievable Resurrection!

    Lead on O King Eternal!

    BZ

  • Creation and Covenant

    Some thoughts about creation and covenant…

    Creation and Covenant. These are the two primary ways in which God is known. In creation we catch the first hint of God, though it’s mysterious and vague. In covenant God is revealed in specific ways to a specific people. God’s sovereignty is established in creation and His redemption is found in covenant.

    Psalm 19 is divided into the dual themes of creation and covenant.

    Psalm 19:1-6 Creation
    (Notice the references to nature and creation; e.g. heavens, skies, day and night, the sun.)

    The heavens tell of the glory of God.
    The skies display his marvelous craftsmanship.
    Day after day they continue to speak;
    Night after night they make him known.
    They speak without a sound or a word;
    Their voice is silent in the skies;
    Yet their message has gone out to all the earth,
    And their words to all the world.
    The sun lives in the heavens
    Where God placed it.
    It bursts forth like a radiant bridegroom
    After his wedding.
    It rejoices like a great athlete
    Eager to run the race.
    The sun rises at one end of the heavens
    And follows its course to the other end.
    Nothing can hide from its heat.

    Psalm 19:7-14 Covenant
    (Notice the references to the Law — the foundation of the Old Covenant; e.g. law, decree, commandment)

    The law of the Lord is perfect,
    Reviving the soul.
    The decrees of the Lord are trustworthy,
    Making wise the simple.
    The commandments of the Lord are right,
    Bringing joy to the heart.
    The commands of the Lord are clear,
    Giving insight to life.
    Reverence for the Lord is pure,
    Lasting forever.
    The laws of the Lord are true;
    Each one is fair.
    They are more desirable than gold,
    Even the finest gold.
    They are sweeter than honey,
    Even honey dripping from the comb.
    They are a warning to those who hear them;
    There is great reward for those who obey them.
    How can I know all the sins lurking in my heart?
    Cleanse me from these hidden faults.
    Keep me from deliberate sins!
    Don’t let them control me.
    Then I will be free of guilt
    And innocent of great sin.
    May the words of my mouth and the thoughts of my heart
    Be pleasing to you,
    O Lord, my rock and my redeemer.

    Notice that what the sun does in creation the law does in the soul: brings light. And both the sun (creation) and the law (covenant) are related to great joy.

    You will also notice that the final thought of Psalm 19 is about redemption. God’s sovereignty is established in creation but His redemption is found in covenant.

    The more connected to nature a society is, the more there is an a priori sense of God’s sovereignty. It is only where man creates an artificial, industrial, technological society that people lose their sense of obligation to God or the gods. The atheist is the child who spent too much time indoors.

    I love God’s creation.
    I’m at home in it.
    It is my home.
    It’s in my bones.
    I am star dust.

    But I am animated star dust. And more than that, I have the breath of God in me so that I can know and interact with the Creator. I am a synthesis of heaven and earth. I am an interface between the heavens and the earth. To walk in a conscious and interactive awareness of God in the garden of creation is what I was uniquely designed to do. To hike and pray in the mountains may be the holiest thing I do.

    Adam was the son of God in creation.
    Abraham was the son of God in covenant.

    God chose Abraham’s family to undo the sin of Adam’s family. But, while Abraham’s family was the solution, they were also part of the problem. They were sinners also.

    From Adam’s family came the Gentile nations of the fallen world.

    From Abraham’s family came the nation of Israel chosen to be God’s agent of redemption.

    But though Israel did bring a measure of light and justice to the world through the Law and the Prophets, by in large they failed in their mission to be God’s redemptive community.

    So the Son of God took the role of Israel upon himself.
    Emmanuel took the role of the Servant of God.
    (This is one of the primary prophetic themes of Isaiah.)

    Isaiah 53 prophesies the suffering, sin-bearing servant:
    My righteous Servant will justify many
    For He will bear all their sins

    Isaiah 54 prophesies a new covenant:
    For the mountains may depart and the hills disappear,
    But even then I will remain loyal to you
    My covenant of blessing will never be broken
    Says the Lord, who has mercy on you.

    Isaiah 55 prophesies a new creation:
    Where once there were thorns, cypress trees will grow
    Where briers grew, myrtles will sprout up
    This miracle will bring great honor to the Lord’s name
    It will be an everlasting sign of his power and love.

    And of course this is what Jesus did in his redemptive work as God’s suffering servant.

    In the Upper Room at the last supper he announced the new covenant.

    In the Upper Room on Easter night he breathed on his disciples to confer new creation.

    So that the Gospel is all about the new creation and the new covenant giving birth to the new kingdom, the new Israel, the new humanity.

    More of the Big Picture of the Big Thing!

    (It’s important to keep working on getting the big picture or you will compartmentalize the Bible into an anthology of unrelated moral truths and wise sayings from which it is impossible to make a coherent story. Never forget that the Bible is telling one big story!)

    “Christianity is not about religion — it’s about humanity, and making it as God intended it to be.
    -Dietrich Bonhoeffer (20th century German theologian)

    “Christianity is an entirely new way of being human.”
    -Maximus the Confessor (7th century bishop)

    “The glory of God is a human being fully alive.”
    -Irenaeus (2nd century church father)

    “Now I’m going to ride my motorcycle through God’s great creation.”
    -Brian Zahnd (21st century pastor)

  • Virginia Tech

    Babylon is fallen, baby
    It’s haunted by hate birds
    I’m talking about the United States of Babylon
    The American Dream gone bad
    Somebody change the channel!
    It’s turned into a malevolent nightmare
    In the land of the free and the home of the…

    A is for Addicted
    B is for Bored
    C is for Consumer

    You get the idea.

    When success is equated with excess
    The ambition for excess wrecks us

    (A swift kick from Switchfoot)

    And so we’re lost in space
    (Danger, Will Robinson!)
    My space, cyber space
    Lonely place, lost grace

    Most are just sad and empty
    But some turn bad, and what was it?
    “Just plain mean”
    And so, mister, a sister (our sister) cries,
    “He made the world weep”

    A generation ago
    Four dead in Ohio
    It made you mad
    You could protest
    Even write a song

    But 32 in Virginia?
    You can’t write a song
    You can only weep
    32 lost and wept over by those beyond console
    And the thirty-third lost to the black hole
    The black hole that took over his soul

    Hell

    Heaven is not a distant place
    Heaven is a different dimension
    Heaven is closer than you think
    Heaven is closer than your next breath
    Heaven is a kingdom of a different kind
    Heaven’s kingdom has come
    To a thin place near you

    A thin place
    The interface between God’s space and my space
    The sacred space of God’s grace

    Hope

    Thy kingdom come, Thy will be done
    Audacious hope subverting the tyranny of the status quo
    Absurd hope almost too embarrassing to talk about
    Daring hope challenging the grandiose pretension of the present
    Divine hope that alone can enable us to smile upon the future
    Thy kingdom come, Thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven

    Repent, the beginning is near!

    -Blind Man at the Gate

  • The Poetic and the Prophetic

    Be wary of blogs written after midnight, but here goes…

    The poetic and the prophetic are related and the prophetic is best conveyed by poetry.

    The Old Testament prophets were all poets to one degree or another and nearly all Hebrew prophecy is poetic in nature. Prose is the vehicle for inert information; but poetry is the magic carpet of prophetic imagination. Prose is the precise tool for telling what is; poetry is the mystical means of imagining what could be. Prose is the small room of fixed reality; poetry unlocks the door to infinite possibility.

    The poetic and the prophetic are related.

    This is certainly true with the book of Revelation. Approach John’s mysterious Patmos poem, not as you would a German theologian’s exegesis of Romans, but as you would a T.S. Elliot poem. Don’t “interpret” Revelation (we both know you’ll get it wrong), but hop on the magic carpet of poetry and let it take you for a wild ride and just see if you don’t come back different.

    Here’s a new thought: The apostolic is related to the apocalyptic. The apostle operates from a motive of eschatology and not expediency.

    (Mysticism trumps pragmaticism.)

    Did I say Trump?

    That reminds me…

    American consumer Christianity has thought the Gospel is best communicated as a kind of business plan or investment prospectus; thus, deplorable books like, Jesus CEO.

    But the Gospel is not a prospectus, it is a story.
    And poets are the best storytellers.

    You could tell the Gospel in the form of Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey, but never as Donald Trump’s, How To Get Rich.

    What am I saying? At least this: We shouldn’t try to turn prophets into corporate executives or imagine apostles as politicians!

    But I digress…

    Back to the poetic and the prophetic.

    At the risk of sounding as though I’m being trite (I am not!), let me identify the essential element of happiness: It is HOPE. Hope by its very nature is prophetic. And prophetic hope is always best imparted through poetry. Hope is the magic carpet of prophetic imagination.

    Walter Brueggemann says this in his book The Prophetic Imagination:

    “The task of prophetic imagination and ministry is to bring to public expression those very hopes and yearnings that have been denied so long and suppressed so deeply that we no longer know why they are there. Hope, on the one hand, is an absurdity too embarrassing to speak about, for it flies in the face of all those claims we have been told are facts. Hope is the refusal to accept the reading of reality which is the majority opinion. On the other hand, hope is subversive, for it limits the grandiose pretension of the present, daring to announce that the present to which we have all made commitments is now called into question. Those who would be prophetic will need to embrace that absurd practice and that subversive activity. Hope is the primary prophetic idiom not because of the general dynamic of history or because of the signs of the times but because the prophet speaks to a people who are God’s people.”

    Rock on, Brueggemann!

    Eugene Peterson in The Contemplative Pastor says this about the poetic pastor:

    The Apocalyptic pastor is a poet. St. John was the first major poet of the Christian church. He used words in new ways, making (poetes in Greek is maker) truth right before our eyes. The way a pastor uses the language is a critical element in the work. The Christian gospel is rooted in language: God spoke a creation into being; our Savior was the Word made flesh. The poet is the person who uses words not primarily to convey information, but to make a relationship, shape beauty, form truth. This is St. John’s work; it is every pastor’s work.

    If St. John’s Revelation is not read as a poem, it is virtually incomprehensible, which, in fact, is why it is so often uncomprehended.

    Isn’t it odd that pastors, who are responsible for interpreting the Scriptures, so much of which come in the form of poetry, have so little interest in poetry? It is a crippling defect and must be remedied. The Christian communities as a whole must rediscover poetry, and pastors must lead them.

    [But] people are most comfortable with prose. They prefer explanations of Bible history and information on God. This is appealing to the pastor, for we have a lot of information to hand out and are adept at explanations. After a few years of speaking in prose, we become prosaic.

    Then a dose of apocalyptic stops us in mid-sentence; the power of the word to create faith.

    Not all words create. Some merely communicate. They explain, report, describe, manage, inform, regulate. We live in an age obsessed with communication. Communication is good but a minor good. Knowing about things never has seemed to improve our lives a great deal. The pastoral task with words is not communication but communion — the healing and restoration and creation of love relationships between God and his fighting children and our fought-over creation. Poetry uses words in and for communion.

    Words making truth, not just conveying it: liturgy and story and song and prayer are the work of pastors who are poets.

    I can’t tell you how happy it made me to read that from Eugene Peterson. It affirmed and vividly expressed some things I have intuitively believed about the nature of preaching. It encourages me to trust my instinct to be far less prosaic and far more poetic/prophetic. Poetry is the language of passion.

    One more quote on the poetic and prophetic imagination. This is from Alison Morgan and her brilliant book The Wild Gospel (this hard to get book is now available in Solomon’s Porch!):

    “Everything Jesus said and did pointed to a new reality. He came not with a manifesto of political reform, but with a new concept of kingdom. He came not with a new ethic, but with a new vision. The Sermon on the Mount makes sense only if we see it as a poetic text, as the prophetic imagining of an alternative world; for the kingdom of God is within before it is without, and must be looked for as inner reality before it can take shape as outer reality.”

    The primary purpose of poetry is for the prophetic imagining of an alternative world: The Kingdom of God!

    The poetic and the prophetic are related.

    And Jesus is the greatest poet of all.

    After the seas are all cross’d, (as they seem already cross’d,)
    After the great captains and engineers have accomplish’d their work,
    After the noble inventors, after the scientists, the chemists, the geologist, ethnologist,
    Finally shall come the poet worthy of that name,
    The true son of God shall come singing his songs.

    -Walt Whitman, Leaves of Grass

    Finally shall come the Poet.

    Maranatha!

    BZ

  • Transcendent and Subversive

    Transcendent

    So if you’re serious about living this new resurrection life with Christ,
    Act like it and seek the transcendent realities,
    Where Christ is, seated at the right hand of God.
    Set your thoughts on transcendent realities,
    Don’t only think about things here on the earth.

    Your old life is dead.
    Your new life, which is your real life,
    (even though invisible to spectators)
    Is with Christ in God.
    When Christ, who is your real life, is revealed to the whole world,
    Then you also will be revealed, the real you, the glorious you.

    Subversive

    Therefore, put to death the sinful and base things lurking within you:
    Sexual promiscuity
    Impurity
    Lust
    Shameful desire
    The idolatry of greed

    Because of these things, the wrath of God is coming.
    You used to do them when your life was still part of this world.
    But now you must put them all away.

    Get these things out of your mouth:
    Anger
    Rage
    Meanness
    Blasphemy
    Foul language

    Don’t lie to one another — you’re done with that old self,
    And have put on the new self,
    Which is continually being renewed in a true knowledge
    According to the image of its Creator.

    In this new life it doesn’t matter if you are:
    Jewish or Gentile
    Circumcised or Uncircumcised
    Sophisticated or Unsophisticated
    Backward and Uneducated
    Poor or Rich
    Christ is what counts — all and in all.

    (Paraphrase of Colossians 3:1-11 adapted from NKJV, NASB, NIV, RSV, ESV, NLT, The Message and Thayer’s Greek Definitions)

    Transcendent and Subversive
    Overcoming with the risen Christ.
    Undermining the fallen world order.

    I was praying in the Upper Room last week, praying through the Five Words.
    I had this thought:

    CROSS = a costly Christianity
    MYSTERY = a mystical Christianity
    ECLECTIC = a rich Christianity
    COMMUNITY = a shared Christianity

    But when I came to the fifth word, REVOLUTION, I was stumped for a moment. So I prayed, “What is revolutionary Christianity?” Immediately this shot into my mind:

    REVOLUTION = a subversive Christianity

    subversion:
    the attempt to overthrow or undermine a government or system by people working from within.

    So is Christianity a subversive Kingdom?

    Absolutely!

    Jesus said:

    “The Kingdom of Heaven is like leaven, which a woman took and hid in three measures of flour, till it was all leavened.” (Matthew 13:33)

    G.K. Chesterton said it this way:

    “Christianity, even when watered down, is hot enough to boil all modern society to rags. The mere minimum of the Church would be a deadly ultimatum to the world.” (Orthodoxy, The Eternal Revolution)

    First John the Baptist, then Jesus, came making this startling and subversive announcement: God’s Kingdom is now invading the world! Jesus made it clear that this kingdom would upset the established order of the old kingdoms. If you really hear what Jesus was saying in its historical and cultural context, you will realize that Jesus was not uttering harmless pious platitudes, but what he was saying was incendiary, revolutionary and subversive. When Jesus said things like, many who are first will be last, and the last first, the Pharisees and Sadducees certainly understood this as undermining their power structure.

    In his death, burial and resurrection, Jesus formed the new kingdom, the new covenant, the new Israel and the new humanity. In time, this new world that Jesus had formed would turn the old world upside down.

    When the Apostle Paul began to preach the Gospel of the Kingdom in the Gentile world it was like a spearhead being thrust into the heart of the Roman Empire. After a few centuries the entire Empire had been undermined by the subversive message of the Kingdom of Heaven.

    Authentic Christianity has always been a subversive threat to the Babylon of the established fallen world order.

    Accommodating Christianity has always been an accomplice to Babylon; serving as a chaplain to the culture of the fallen world order.

    Authentic Christianity is a danger. A danger to any system established upon the values of Babylon.

    Accommodating Christianity is a whore. A whore selling religious favors for the price of public approval.

    I refuse to be a chaplain to the culture of the fallen world order.

    I refuse to be an accomplice in the deception called “the American dream.”

    I refuse to be a priest offering peace offerings on the altar of the status quo.

    I am a dangerous Christian. I am a subversive.

    I believe the kingdoms of this world are doomed to destruction.

    I believe the kingdoms of this world will be replaced by the Kingdom of Christ.

    I believe that Kingdom is already at work, undermining the foundations of Babylon.

    Alison Morgan in her brilliant book, The Wild Gospel, says:

    “We stand, in the church, at the end of a long process of accommodation in which we have unconsciously sought to harmonize the gospel with the assumptions of our culture, a culture which in abandoning the quest for absolute truth has embraced a new set of values — rationalistic, materialistic, technological, and reductionist. The effect has been that we have gradually turned the gospel from something subversive and life-changing to something tamed, packaged and institutionalized; from something expressed in words of power to something conveyed, if it is conveyed at all, in words of information.”

    The fallen world order of the decedent West is governed by three things:
    MONEY, SEX and SELF (to put it positively)
    GREED, LUST and PRIDE (to put it negatively)

    I am actively at work to undermine these three pillars of Babylon. Not by protest or political means (those are not the methods of a subversive), but by influencing people to transfer their loyalty from Babylon to the New Jerusalem. When a person really does transfer their loyalty to the New Jerusalem, the controlling characteristics of greed, lust and pride lose their hold upon the person and they become a counterculture Kingdom subversive. This is how the world is turned upside down!

    Mysticism and subversion go together.

    Mysticism is seeking the transcendent realities of the risen Christ and the resurrected life.

    Subversion is adopting the values of the New Jerusalem which undermines the demonic trinity of Babylon: Greed, lust and pride.

    We must be both culturally aware and counterculture. Immersed in the culture as the yeast in the dough but distinct from it. Only in this way can we transform our culture.

    Be transcendent and subversive!

    Be mystical and revolutionary!

    BZ

    Seen the arrow on the doorpost
    Saying, “This land is condemned
    All the way from New Orleans
    To Jerusalem.”

    PS

    What I’m reading:

    The Wild Gospel: Bringing Truth to Life by Alison Morgan

    Francis of Assisi: A Revolutionary Life
    by Adrian House
    (Thank you, dinosaurs!)

  • Pulling Back The Curtain

    I’m working on my Friday night message:

    More On Mysticism:
    “Pulling Back The Curtain”

    Mark 1:9-11

    I thought I would share the introduction with you:

    Heaven and earth is the primary division within creation (Genesis 1:1). The heavens are not a distant place within the material universe, but a different dimension. Heaven and Earth are not far apart, but near to one another, overlapping and even intersecting. Some places seem to become a point of common intersection. Ancient Celtic Christians called these “thin places.” A thin place is a sacred space that has become an interface between God’s space and our space. In one sense, the ultimate thin place is the human being. If earth is the domain of animals and heaven the domain of angels, then man, as a hybrid being comprised of both the clay from which he was formed and the spirit which God breathed into him, is suited for both heaven and earth.

    But since the Fall man has been primarily confined to the earth, living as little more than a sophisticated, intelligent bipedal animal, or seeking to gain illegal entry into the heavenly realm through occult means. The Garden of Eden can be looked upon as the place where man was at home in both heaven and earth — enjoying the garden and walking with the Gardener. But with the Fall, the way to the garden was lost (Genesis 3:24). Fallen man, whether he understands it or not, pines for a return to the garden. But, sadly, human attempts to recover the lost garden always end in either disappointment (consider the arts) or tragedy (consider Communism).

    But what man could not recover on his own, God recovered for us. Through the mystery of the Incarnation and the triumph of the Resurrection Jesus Christ has again opened the way to the garden. Consider the implications of these Easter events: The risen Christ first appears in a garden. He moves easily between dimensions, appearing physically in a locked room without going through the door (He is the door!). He breathes upon His disciples to confer the life of new creation even as the Gardener had done in the beginning. The first Easter was the eighth day of the new beginning, the first day of the new creation; it marked the dawn of the true new age and the recovery of the lost garden.

    To walk again with God in the garden is the great desire of humanity and might properly be called the mystical aspect of Christianity (Christian mysticism being defined as the philosophy and practice of a direct experience with God). Christian mysticism is what will save our soul from the madness of the age — the frenzied life of technological tyranny — and enable us to again walk with the Gardener in His garden far from the madding crowd. But to do this we must learn the open secrets of Christian mysticism and put into practice the spiritual disciplines that enable us to part the curtain and step beyond the veil.